PAST THEMES
| Year | Theme | Prize | Captain |
| 1948 | Prince Charming and His Escorts | Bill McIntyre Sr. | |
| 1949 | Shooting Stars | 2 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1950 | Hades On Parade | 1 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1951 | Pride Of Killarney | 1 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1952 | Congo Ceremony | 1 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1953 | The Harem | 1 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1954 | Hawaiian Jubilee | 3 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1955 | Sons Of The Nile | 8 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1956 | Our American Heritage | 2 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1957 | Christmas in Killarney | 9 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1958 | King Jesters | 1 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1959 | Oriental Fans | 1 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1960 | Garden Of Fountains | 5 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1961 | Skaters Waltz | 7 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1962 | Rio Ritual | 6 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1963 | Oriental Temple Dancers | 5 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1964 | Wee Bit of Scotland | 8 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1965 | Hello Dolly | 6 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1966 | The Safaris | 7 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1967 | Satan’s Empire | 12 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1968 | This Land Is Mine | 11 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1969 | Legend Of The Phoenix | 13 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1970 | Buffalo Bills Wild West Show | 12 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1971 | A Persian Market | 12 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1972 | My Lady’s Fan | 16 | Bill McIntyre Sr. |
| 1973 | Broadway Follies | 6 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1974 | Carnival De Brazil | 5 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1975 | Land Of The Aztecs | 13 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1976 | A Time For Celebrating 76 | 13 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1977 | The Mongol Empire | 13 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1978 | Aqua Fantasy | 1 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1979 | World Beyond The Horizon | 6 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1980 | Witches’ Sabbath | 5 | Fran McIntyre |
| 1981 | Utopia | 5 | Bill Morrison |
| 1982 | Masters of the Occult | 1 | Bill Morrison |
| 1983 | Exotic Safari | 8 | Tom Cloney |
| 1984 | Night Of The Wizard | 7 | Tom Cloney |
| 1985 | Dancin | 4 | Bill Morrison |
| 1986 | On Stage At The Mounlin Rouge | 7 | Bill Morrison |
| 1987 | Rockin’ Mountain Madmen | 7 | Bill Morrison |
| 1988 | The Land of Make Believe | 2 | Bill Morrison |
| 1989 | Junkyard Saturday Night | 13 | Bill Morrison |
| 1990 | High Noon at Low Tide | 3 | Bill Morrison |
| 1991 | Flying Down To Rio | 4 | Mickey Adams |
| 1992 | Ghouls Just Wanna Have Fun | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 1993 | Singapore Swing | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 1994 | Outta This World | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 1995 | Toyz In The Hood | 5 | Mickey Adams |
| 1996 | Magical Mystical Tour | 5 | Mickey Adams |
| 1997 | Thunder Drums – A Gathering of Nations | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 1998 | Spirit Of Africa | 2 | Mickey Adams |
| 1999 | Olympus: Myth And Legend | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 2000 | Wonders of Ancient Egypt | 2 | Mickey Adams |
| 2001 | El Dorado – Quest for the City of Gold | 2 | Mickey Adams |
| 2002 | Live At The Museum | 5 | Mickey Adams |
| 2003 | Scotland, Land Of The Clans | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 2004 | Creature Double Feature | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 2005 | Mars Attacks | 4 | Mickey Adams |
| 2006 | Pirates, Lost Treasure of the Abyss | 2 | Mickey Adams |
| 2007 | An Arabian Night’s Tale | 2 | Mickey Adams |
| 2008 | India…Land of the Tiger | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 2009 | Mythic Knights, Defenders Of The Realm | 1 | Mickey Adams |
| 2010 | Tribal Instinct | 2 | Mickey Adams |
| 2011 | Haunted Highlands | 3 | Mickey Adams |
| 2012 | Expedition Everest: Quest for the Yeti | 2 | Michael Adams |
| 2013 | Super Heroes-Super Villians-Super Thrills | 5 | Michael Adams |
| 2014 | Atlantis: Guardians Of The Deep | 1 | Michael Adams |
| 2015 | The Mysterious Island | 2 | Michael Adams |
| 2016 | Happily Never After – A Twisted Tale | 2 | Michael Adams |
| 2017 | The Phantom’s Masquerade | 4 | Michael Adams |
| 2018 | Beyond the Stars | 4 | Michael Adams |
| 2019 | Great Spirit: Legend Of The Dream Catcher | 3 | Michael Adams |
| 2020 | Sinbad And The Curse Of The Nile | 3 | Michael Adams |
| 2022 | Spellbound | 8 | Michael Adams |
| 2023 | Marionettes of the Midway | 8 | Charlie Kapusniak IV |
| 2024 | Voyage Beyond The Horizon | 2 | Charlie Kapusniak IV |
| 2025 | Legend of the Secret Scrolls | 1 | Charlie Kapusniak IV |